math/topology

[증명] If Y is compact, the projection map is a closed map

finding wangdo 2025. 10. 6. 23:46

Proposition.

If Y is compact, the projection map π₁ : X × Y → X is a closed map.

 

Proof

 

Let A be closed in X × Y.

W := X - π₁(A)

 

Fix an x ∈ W

∀y ∈ Y, x × y ∈ X × Y - A and X × Y - A is open.

⇒ ∃open Vy ⊂ X, Uy ⊂ Y s.t. x × y ∈ Vy × Uy ⊂ X × Y - A ( x ∈ Vy and y ∈ Uy )

⇒ { Vy × Uy | y ∈ Y } is an open cover of x × Y contained in X × Y - A

 

Y is compact, so x × Y is compact.

∃ finite subcover { Vi × Ui | i = 1, 2, ..., n } of x × Y contained in X × Y - A

⇒ Vi × Ui and A are disjoint for all i

∀x' ∈ π₁(A), ∃Vi s.t. x'∉Vi

∩Vi is open, and disjoint with π₁(A) (therefore contained in W)

 

[alternative method]

starting from

∃ finite subcover { Vi × Ui | i = 1, 2, ..., n } of x × Y contained in X × Y - A

⇒ { Vi × Ui | i = 1, 2, ..., n } covers the open set ∩Vi × Y and is disjoint with A

⇒ ∩Vi × Y is open and disjoint with A (Here, ∩Vi × Y is a TUBE containing the slice x × Y and contained in X × Y - A : refer to Tube Lemma)

⇒ π₁(∩Vi × Y) = ∩Vi is open and disjoint with π₁(A) (therefore contained in W)

 

 

This concludes that for all x ∈ W, there exists an open neighborhood ∩Vi contained in W.

⇒ W is open

π₁(A) is closed.

 

∴ π₁ is a closed map.

End of proof.

 

 

* Note. What if Y is not compact?

Let X = Y = ℝ in the standard topology

{ x × y | xy = 1 } is closed.

But its projection, which is ℝ - {0} is not closed.

So, the projection is not a closed map.